My Photo
Blog powered by Typepad

UNIMAGINED - a Muslim boy meets the West

« The VERY BEST Possible Outcome (from some perspectives) | Main | YoungMinds Book Award 2007 »

November 07, 2007

Comments

Mark

Sorry Imran, I can't agree with your letter to Ian Blair.

The Stockwell operation was literally a bloody shambles - the blood of an innocent man.

The IPCC report has catalogued 19 failures in the operation. In the light of this, I must disagreee with Ian Blair - the errors were systemic. He is the head of the service and the buck must stop with him.

There are two points I find particularly disturbing. Firstly, the armed officers reckon that they shouted a warning. All the officers heard this, BUT NO ONE ELSE DID. Strange, that! The officers were not operating under KRATOS rules, which would have meant that they didn't have to give a warning.

Secondly, Sir Ian Blair tried to prevent, or at least delay, the IPCC investigation. In this he was preventing the IPCC from carrying out its legal duties.

No one set out that day to kill an innocent man, but it happened - due to 19 failures in the system. The head of that system must, if he has any honour, stand down.

Imran Ahmad

Mark,

You make excellent points: the operation was a shambles, communication was a mess, an innocent man was killed.

But I think this would have happened regardless of who was sitting in the top office. This is new territory for our society, and everyone was very hyped up, the day after the second round of (attempted) suicide bombings.

Sir Ian Blair's resignation would just be a victory for the terrorists - and they are the ones to blame.

We don't want the next police officer in this kind of situation to be thinking: 'If I'm wrong about this, it could cost me my career.' It's an unnecessary additional burden which could cloud their decision-making when they have to be very sharp.

In other words, they need our support and to be confident in the knowledge that we won't crucify them if they make an incorrect call.

Mandy

This is rubbish. Your opinion is completley wrong. You shoudl just keep quiet.

Mark

Imran,

Ian Blair is the head of the Metropolitan Police. Being Commissioner carries with it some excellent rewards (salary etc.) and a lot of kudos.

It also carries with it the responsibility to make sure that the systems are running as they ought to be.

In this particular, Ian Blair has failed. It is up to him to make sure he has the correct people in place to carry out operations in an efficient and lawful way. This did not happen, and Blair did not dismiss any officers over it. Indeed, he promoted the officer in charge of the operation.

Yet you and I agree it was a shambles. The buck must stop at Ian Blair's desk.

Without his resignation, I can no longer believe Ian Blair to be an honourable man.

dovegreyreader

Everyone go read A Question of Trust by Onora O'Neill and then come back and see if you still feel the same.This situation is part of a very big picture indeed imho.

Imran Ahmad

An IBM sales executive screwed up a deal, and cost the company ten million dollars.

He said to his boss: "I guess you're going to fire me now."

His boss replied: "Fire you?! Are you kidding? We've just invested ten million dollars training you."

The comments to this entry are closed.

January 2013

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
    1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31